Research led by Cambridge doctors and scientists shows people who are obese may be more susceptible to severe Covid because of a poorer inflammatory immune response.
Scientists at the Cambridge Institute of Therapeutic Immunology and Infectious Disease (CITIID) and Wellcome Sanger Institute have found that following SARS-CoV-2 infection, cells in the lining of lungs and nasal cells, and immune cells in the blood, show a blunted inflammatory response in obese patients, producing suboptimal levels of molecules needed to fight the infection.
The findings could have important implications both for the treatment of Covid and in the design of clinical trials to test new treatments.
During the pandemic, the majority of younger patients I saw on the Covid wards were obese.
Professor Menna Clatworthy, clinician scientist at the University of Cambridge who also cared for Covid patients at Addenbrooke’s.
Since the start of the pandemic, there have been almost 760 million confirmed cases of SARS-CoV-2 infection, with almost 6.9 million deaths.
While some people have very mild – or even no – symptoms, others have much more severe symptoms, including acute respiratory distress syndrome requiring ventilator support.
One of the major risk factors for severe Covid is obesity, which is defined as a body mass index (BMI) of over 30. More than 40% of US adults and 28% of adults in England are classed as obese.
While this link has been shown in numerous epidemiological studies, until now, it has not been clear why obesity should increase an individual’s risk of severe Covid.
One possible explanation was thought to be that obesity is linked to inflammation: studies have shown that people who are obese already have higher levels of key molecules associated with inflammation in their blood. Could an overactive inflammatory response explain the connection?
Professor Menna Clatworthy is a clinician scientist at the University of Cambridge, studying tissue immune cells at CITIID alongside caring for patients at Addenbrooke’s, part of Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust (CUH). She said:
“During the pandemic, the majority of younger patients I saw on the Covid wards were obese.
"Given what we know about obesity, if you’d asked me why this was the case, I would have said that it was most likely due to excessive inflammation.
"What we found was the absolute opposite.”
Clatworthy and her team analysed blood and lung samples taken from 13 obese patients with severe Covid requiring mechanical ventilation and intensive care treatment, and 20 controls (non-obese Covid patients and ventilated non-Covid patients). These included patients admitted to intensive care at CUH.
Her team used a technique known as transcriptomics, which looks at RNA molecules produced by our DNA, to study activity of cells in these key tissues. Their results are published in the American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine.
Contrary to expectations, the researchers found that the obese patients had underactive immune and inflammatory responses in their lungs.
In particular, when compared to non-obese patients, cells in the lining of their lungs and some of their immune cells had lower levels of activity among genes responsible for the production of two molecules known as interferons (INF) – interferon-alpha and interferon-gamma – which help control the response of the immune system, and of tumour necrosis factor (TNF), which causes inflammation.
When they looked at immune cells in the blood of 42 adults from an independent cohort, they found a similar, but less marked, reduction in the activity of interferon-producing genes as well as lower levels of IFN-alpha in the blood.
Across every cell type we looked at, we found that that the genes responsible for the classical antiviral response were less active.
Professor Meena Clatworthy
Professor Clatworthy said:
“This was really surprising and unexpected. Across every cell type we looked at, we found that that the genes responsible for the classical antiviral response were less active. They were completely muted.”
What we’ve shown is that not all patients are the same, so we might need to tailor treatments.
Co-author Dr Andrew Conway Morris, a consultant in intensive care at Addenbrooke’s.
The team was able to replicate its findings in nasal immune cells taken from obese children with Covid, where they again found lower levels of activity among the genes that produce IFN-alpha and IFN-gamma.
This is important because the nose is one of the entry points for the virus – a robust immune response there could prevent the infection spreading further into the body, while a poorer response would be less effective.
One possible explanation for the finding involves leptin, a hormone produced in fat cells that controls appetite.
Leptin also plays a role in the immune response: in individuals who are normal weight, levels of the hormone increase in response to infection and it directly stimulates immune cells.
But obese people already have chronically higher levels of leptin, and Clatworthy says it is possible that they no longer produce sufficient additional leptin in response to infection, or are insensitive to it, leading to inadequate stimulation of their immune cells.
The findings could have important implications both for the treatment of Covid and in the design of clinical trials to test new treatments.
Because an overactive immune and inflammatory response can be associated with severe Covid in some patients, doctors have turned to anti-inflammatory drugs to dampen this response.
But anti-inflammatory drugs may not be appropriate for obese patients.
Co-author Dr Andrew Conway Morris from the Department of Medicine at the University of Cambridge and a consultant in intensive care at Addenbrooke’s said:
“What we’ve shown is that not all patients are the same, so we might need to tailor treatments. Obese subjects might need less anti-inflammatory treatments and potentially more help for their immune system.”
Clinical trials for potential new treatments would need to involve stratifying patients rather than including both severe and normal weight patients, whose immune responses differ.
The research was largely supported by Wellcome, the Medical Research Council and the National Institute of Health Research, including via the NIHR Cambridge Biomedical Research Centre.
Reference
Guo, SA, Bowyer, GS, Ferdinand, JR, Maes, M & Tuong, ZK et al. Obesity associated with attenuated tissue immune cell responses in COVID-19. Am J Resp Critical Care Med; 1 Mar 2023; DOI: 10.1164/rccm.202204-0751OC